Menu of Three Brothers From Italy Pizza in Ocean City, New Jersey, USA

Menu Overview

Three Brothers From Italy Pizza, nestled on the bustling 1030 Boardwalk in Ocean City, NJ, stands out as a classic destination for pizza lovers seeking generous portions and authentic flavors. The atmosphere is straightforward—order at the counter, find a seat, and wait for your fresh, piping-hot pizza to be delivered. This no-frills setup blends perfectly with the vibrant boardwalk vibe, where the focus is clearly on quality and taste rather than pomp.

The menu boasts an impressive variety of pizzas, with highlights including the iconic Plain Cheese Pizza Slice, the fresh and aromatic Margherita Pizza, and the uniquely creamy Spinach Ricotta Cheese Pizza Slice. Each slice here is a statement of size and flavor—often larger than expected, demanding space and an appetite.

One of the defining qualities of Three Brothers’ offerings is their balanced use of classic and inventive toppings. The Chicken Bacon Ranch is a savory blend that caters to those craving smoky, hearty notes, while the BBQ Chicken Pizza introduces a tangy, sweet twist that contrasts beautifully with the mozzarella’s richness. Sausage fans can delight in the well-seasoned Sausage Pizza and its slice counterpart, both delivering robust, meaty satisfaction.

Vegetarian options hold their own with savory choices like Spinach, Mushroom, and Broccoli Tomato, providing fresh, earthy undertones that balance the cheese-centric base. The White Pizza and Ricotta Slice extend the menu’s appeal for those favoring creamy textures over traditional red sauce.

Side orders such as the Small and Large Curly Cheese Fries are indulgent complements—crispy, cheesy, and generously portioned—perfect for sharing or savoring alone with a bottled water to wash down the richness.

Customer reviews back up the menu’s quality. Laub Knight highlights the “gigantic” size of the plain pizza slice, noting it demanded improvisation with paper plates but satisfied all palates, especially for simple tastes. Tom Aquilone declares Three Brothers the top contender in a rigorous shorewide pizza shootout, especially lauding their cheese and pepperoni options. Katherine McCord’s tradition of craving “BIG slices” annually resonates with any pizza aficionado who values fresh pies and fast, friendly service, even though seating can be tight and competitive.

From Constance Scott, the melding of “huge slices” with an unmatched Atlantic Ocean view encapsulates the quintessential Jersey Shore pizza experience—simple food, bold flavors, and memorable ambiance. Mike Newport’s poignant mention of the buffalo chicken pizza, ready in just ten minutes and packed with punchy seasoning, adds testament to Three Brothers’ consistency across seasons.

For anyone visiting Ocean City’s boardwalk, Three Brothers From Italy Pizza serves as an emblem of generous, authentic New Jersey pizza culture. Their menu caters to diverse tastes, balances tradition with creativity, and delivers hearty slices that satisfy both locals and vacationers alike. Whether you’re a fan of classic cheese or adventurous toppings, be prepared for large portions, fresh ingredients, and an unmistakable atmosphere where pizza is at the forefront.